How the numbers are calculated
There are two views of the same building. Living there: what it costs you each month after the other units’ rent. Moved out: whether it works as a straight rental once your unit is rented too, which is what decides whether you keep it.
Mortgage insurance is charged on the base loan. With the FHA preset (under 10% down) it applies for the life of the loan; with conventional it applies only while you’re under 20% down; VA has none but charges a funding fee. The presets are illustrative starting points, so swap in your lender’s quote.
Worked example
A $420,000 duplex with an FHA loan: 3.5% down, 6.5% rate, 1.75% upfront premium financed, 0.55% annual MI. You live in one side; the other rents for $2,600.
| Down payment (3.5%) | $14,700 |
| Total loan ($405,300 + $7,093 fee) | $412,393 |
| Principal & interest | $2,606.60 |
| Mortgage insurance ($405,300 × 0.55% ÷ 12) | $185.76 |
| Taxes + insurance + utilities | $708.33 |
| Cost to own, no tenants | $3,500.70 |
| Less net rent from unit 2 ($2,600 less 20% for vacancy, repairs, capex) | −$2,080.00 |
| Your net housing cost | $1,420.70 |
So you’d live there for about $1,421 a month instead of $3,501, with $27,300 to close ($14,700 down + $12,600 closing). Moved out, with your side renting for $2,400, NOI is $3,291.67 a month against $2,792.36 of P&I plus MI: $499 a month of cash flow and a 1.26x DSCR.
Practitioner notes
- Compare the net housing cost with what you pay in rent today, not with zero. Paying $1,421 to own a duplex can beat paying rent for a one-bedroom.
- FHA and VA loans require you to live in the property (FHA generally for at least a year). Plan the move-out year now.
- Budget repairs and capex even while you live there. You’re the landlord now, and the water heater doesn’t know you’re an owner-occupant.